Vinyl Verdicts: Song Reviews

YouTube Videos

June 22, 2026

New Music Worth Your Time? Vinyl Verdicts Decides

New Music Worth Your Time? Vinyl Verdicts Decides

Every week Radio Garden State adds new music to the rotation, but this week Chris and Rachel are putting those songs on trial. From punk and indie rock to alternative, power pop, ska, and everything in between, they'll listen, debate, and deliver their Vinyl Verdict. Which songs deserve a permanent…

View more
June 7, 2026

What Are the Best Songs About Family?

What Are the Best Songs About Family?

Family. We've all got one. This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we're spinning songs that celebrate the people who raised us, inspired us, drove us crazy, and helped make us who we are. Chris and Rachel each bring three songs about family to the table and put them through the ultimate…

View more
June 1, 2026

Vinyl Verdicts Goes Down Under

Vinyl Verdicts Goes Down Under

🇦🇺 VINYL VERDICTS GOES DOWN UNDER 🇦🇺 Our #1 listener from Australia, Ian, sent us 6 songs to put through the official Vinyl Verdicts test. Will they be hidden gems? Future favorites? Or will they leave us scratching our heads? Chris and Rachel listen, react, debate, and rate every song…

View more
May 25, 2026

Songs That Belong at Every Summer Cookout

Songs That Belong at Every Summer Cookout

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, Chris and Rachel are serving up the ultimate Cookout Jams playlist — the songs that instantly feel like summer. We’re talking backyard BBQ anthems, chill groove classics, windows-down singalongs, funky party starters, and those songs that somehow make burgers taste better. Each of us picked…

View more
May 24, 2026

The Ultimate Graduation Playlist

The Ultimate Graduation Playlist

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re creating The Graduation Mixtape — songs about freedom, growing up, moving on, and stepping into whatever comes next. Some songs capture the excitement of finally getting out on your own. Others hit that weird mix of nostalgia, fear, independence, and possibility that comes with…

View more
May 11, 2026

The Ultimate Graduation Playlist

The Ultimate Graduation Playlist

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re creating The Graduation Mixtape — songs about freedom, growing up, moving on, and stepping into whatever comes next. Some songs capture the excitement of finally getting out on your own. Others hit that weird mix of nostalgia, fear, independence, and possibility that comes with…

View more
May 7, 2026

Millennium Falcon Mixtape (May the 4th Special)

Millennium Falcon Mixtape (May the 4th Special)

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re blasting off for a May the 4th special with the Millennium Falcon Mixtape. We built a massive playlist for this one… then each of us pulled 3 songs to swap, defend, and rate on our 1–5 record scale. No rules. No genres. Just the…

View more
May 7, 2026

If the Millennium Falcon Had a Cassette Deck…

If the Millennium Falcon Had a Cassette Deck…

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we Took the Aux Cord Into Hyperspace and created the ultimate Millennium Falcon Mixtape, featuring an eclectic mix of songs that would make even Han Solo raise an eyebrow. We're putting tracks like Britney Spears' "Toxic " and David Bowie's "Rebel Rebel" to the test,…

View more
May 7, 2026

Top Rainy Day Playlist Songs

Top Rainy Day Playlist Songs

When the rain starts falling, the right song just hits different. This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re diving into the ultimate rainy day soundtrack—songs about rain, songs that feel like rain, and songs that hit you right in that quiet, reflective mood. From iconic classics to unexpected picks, we’re each…

View more
May 4, 2026

Millennium Falcon Mixtape (May the 4th Special)

Millennium Falcon Mixtape  (May the 4th Special)

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re blasting off for a May the 4th special with the Millennium Falcon Mixtape. We built a massive playlist for this one… then each of us pulled 3 songs to swap, defend, and rate on our 1–5 record scale. No rules. No genres. Just the…

View more
April 29, 2026

Is Hinder’s Lips of Angle the Mt Everest of BUTT ROCK

Is Hinder’s Lips of Angle the Mt Everest  of BUTT ROCK
View more
April 27, 2026

Rainy Day Playlist Songs

Rainy Day Playlist Songs

When the rain starts falling, the right song just hits different. This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re diving into the ultimate rainy day soundtrack—songs about rain, songs that feel like rain, and songs that hit you right in that quiet, reflective mood. From iconic classics to unexpected picks, we’re each…

View more
April 25, 2026

6 Songs For Your Spring Playlist

6 Songs For Your Spring Playlist

Spring is in the air—and so are the vibes. On this episode of Vinyl Verdicts: Song Reviews, Chris and Rachel each bring three songs that capture the feeling of spring. From upbeat indie tracks to nostalgic classics, we’re breaking down the songs that feel like sunshine, fresh starts, and open…

View more
April 20, 2026

Butt Rock: Actually Good or Just Nostalgia?

Butt Rock: Actually Good or Just Nostalgia?

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re diving headfirst into the world of BUTT ROCK… and yeah, we’re owning it. You know the songs. You’ve heard them a thousand times. You probably said you hated them… but somehow still know every word. From massive radio hits to overplayed anthems, we’re putting…

View more
April 11, 2026

Weezer “Shine Again” Review + VINYL VERDICT

Weezer “Shine Again” Review + VINYL VERDICT

Join Chris and Rachel for a brand new song reaction as they dive into the latest from Weezer, "Shine Again." Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use…

View more
April 11, 2026

Your Favorite Band Then vs. Now

Your Favorite Band Then vs. Now

Are your favorite artists actually getting better… or just older?This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re going Then vs. Now—comparing each artist’s first hit single to what they’re releasing today.Same band. Same name. But are they still delivering?We each picked three artists and put them head-to-head:👉 The song that made them…

View more
April 6, 2026

The Spring Vibe Soundtrack

The Spring Vibe Soundtrack

Spring is in the air—and so are the vibes. On this episode of Vinyl Verdicts: Song Reviews, Chris and Rachel each bring three songs that capture the feeling of spring. From upbeat indie tracks to nostalgic classics, we’re breaking down the songs that feel like sunshine, fresh starts, and open…

View more
March 30, 2026

Old Hits vs New Songs (Some of These Hurt)

Old Hits vs New Songs (Some of These Hurt)

Are your favorite artists actually getting better… or just older? This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re going Then vs. Now—comparing each artist’s first hit single to what they’re releasing today. Same band. Same name. But are they still delivering? We each picked three artists and put them head-to-head: 👉 The…

View more
March 30, 2026

Cover Songs vs Originals… Who Did It Better?

Cover Songs vs Originals… Who Did It Better?

This week on Vinyl Verdicts: Music Reviews, Chris and Rachel take on one of the biggest debates in music: Cover Songs vs. Originals. Some covers completely reinvent a song and become bigger than the original. Others? Let’s just say… they should’ve stayed in the studio. We each picked songs that…

View more
March 28, 2026

Caught in the Echo: Are Foo Fighters Back?

Caught in the Echo: Are Foo Fighters Back?

Join Chris and Rachel for a brand new song reaction as they dive into the latest from Foo Fighters, "Caught in the Echo." While big fans of their earlier work, they discuss their thoughts on the new alternative rock track. Get ready for their honest opinions on this new rock…

View more
March 24, 2026

Muse 'Be With You" | Complete Reaction

Muse 'Be With You" | Complete Reaction

Join Chris and Rachel as they react to the Muse official music video for "Be With You." This episode features their first listen and review of the new music from the alternative rock band. Don't miss their honest thoughts and discussion on this latest release! Get vidIQ to grow your…

View more
March 22, 2026

Cover Songs vs Originals… Who Did It Better?

Cover Songs vs Originals… Who Did It Better?

This week on Vinyl Verdicts: Music Reviews, Chris and Rachel take on one of the biggest debates in music: Cover Songs vs. Originals. Some covers completely reinvent a song and become bigger than the original. Others? Let’s just say… they should’ve stayed in the studio. We each picked songs that…

View more
March 17, 2026

Songs About Booze & Getting Drunk | St. Patrick’s Day Episode

Songs About Booze & Getting Drunk | St. Patrick’s Day Episode

This week on Vinyl Verdicts, we’re raising a glass for St. Patrick’s Day with a theme that music has celebrated for decades: songs about drinking, booze, and getting a little drunk. From classic pub anthems to rowdy rock songs and a few unexpected picks, there’s definitely no shortage of music…

View more
March 17, 2026

Songs to Skip or Play? We Tested It

Songs to Skip or Play? We Tested It

We took a look at the most skipped songs. Do you agree with this list? What songs make your skip list? Let us know - we want to hear from you! Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such…

View more